You really like us!


Since opening in 2007, we have been honored again and again as a top cupcake bakery:
Internationally: “25 Sweet Cupcake Shops Around the World to Eat at Before You Die” (ranked 14th) * Best Cupcake in THE WORLD (“Where to Eat the Best Cupcake in the World“) Nationally: PAULA DEEN’s “Ten To Try*Best Cupcake in Indiana” by CNN *Best Cupcake in Indiana” by MSN *Top 50 Cupcake Bakery in America” by *Absolute 10 Best Cupcake Shops in the U.S.” by *Top 10 Cupcake in the Midwest” by Midwest Living Magazine
Locally: Voter’s Choice/Editor’s choice as Indy’s Best Cupcake from IndyStar*Nuvo* Indy’s A-List*Indianapolis Monthly  and so many more! ” WOW!

Visit Our Five Indy Locations!

Carmel: 831 S. Rangeline Rd,  Carmel
Sunday 12-5; Tues-Thurs 10-7; Fri & Sat 10-8 Closed Monday

Castleton/Keystone: 4026 E. 82nd Street, Indianapolis
Sunday 12-5; Tues-Thurs 10-7; Fri & Sat 10-8 Closed Monday

Greenwood: 789 U.S. 31 North, Suite D, Greenwood
Sunday 12-5; Tues-Thurs 10-7; Fri & Sat 10-8 Closed Monday

Downtown Indy: 423 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis
Sunday 12-5; Tuesday – Thursday 10:30-7; Fri & Sat 10:30-8 Closed Monday

BroadRipple: 1134 E. 54th Street (54th & Monon)
(Our 5617 N. Illinois St., Indianapolis has MOVED)
Currently OPEN Fri & Sat 10-8 Closed Sunday-Thursday 

Contact Us!

Phone: 317-396-2696
Email Us

Join Our Crew!

Meet Our Crew of Cupcake Masterminds!



The Big Cheese & Owner

Kate’s Favorite Cupcake:
A Black Bottom Cheesecake microwaved for about 5 seconds, with a dab of Auf Wiedersehen topping (a Kate Drury Custom Creation™)
“Well-behaved women seldom make history.” – Laurel Thatcher Ulrich



Chief Happiness Officer & Front-of-House GM

Carol’s Favorite Cupcake:
V/GF Lemon Almond Yogurt–gone but never forgotten
“A girl should be two things; classy and fabulous.” -Coco Chanel



Bakery General Manager & Cake Artist in Residence

Jessalyn’s Favorite Cupcake:
Black Raspberry Truffle
We need to remember what’s important in life: friends, waffles, work. Or waffles, friends, work. Doesn’t matter, but work is third.” – Leslie Knope



Assistant General Manager/ Swiss Army Knife

Taylor’s Favorite Cupcake:
Raspberry Ripple
“If  you can’t be unafraid, be afraid and happy.”― Maggie Stiefvater, The Raven King

Our Refund & Cancellation Policy

ALL SALES ARE FINAL. We limit the number of orders we accept on any given day. Preparations for your order begin well in advance of actually baking your order, including ordering ingredients and scheduling staff. For this reason, there are absolutely no refunds or store credits issued after payment has been made, including cancellations due to Covid-19.  Should you need to cancel your order, we will not issue you a refund or store credit; we do not accept changes to your pickup date within 7 days of your original pickup date. For these reasons we strongly suggest you wait to place your order until you’re absolutely certain.

Allergen Disclaimer

ALL products are baked in a shared kitchen on shared equipment with products containing gluten, dairy/animal products, and nuts.  All equipment is sanitized between use. However, we cannot and do not guarantee that cross contamination will not occur.  Consult with your Healthcare Provider for guidance and advise as to if our products are safe for your consumption. Ingredients available upon request.

GLUTEN FREE products contain dairy 

VEGAN/DAIRY FREE products contain gluten