We love custom orders! Not to brag (bragging is forthcoming) but we are kind of good at making cutie pie cakes! Please note that full payment is required at the time you place your order. Also, and logically, because we order ingredients in advance, we accept cancellations for a full refund up to and through 8 days before your original order pick up date. Cancellations made 7 days through 3 days prior to the original order pick up date may be made but only for in-store credit good for 6 months from date of cancellation. Sorry but we cannot issue refunds or in-store credits for any orders cancelled within 2 days of the original pick up date.  

In addition to being Indy’s most popular cupcake bakery, the Flying Cupcake proudly bakes and decorates thousand of cakes for our customers every year! While we don't work with fondant (#fondantsucks), we do work with 100% from-scratch buttercream, cream cheese, white/dark/milk chocolate ganache on all of our cakes! Our decorators are not just cake decorates, but local artists so you can order with confidence that your cake will be visually as delicious as it is taste-wise.


Sheet Cake (feeds 20-25) $79.95

8” Standard Round 2-Layer (feeds 8-10) $59.95

8” Round 2-Layer Floral, Ombré, or Ruffle Cake (feeds 8-10) $79.95

8” Round 2-Layer Unicorn Cake (feeds 8-10) $89.95

8” Round 2-Layer Special Character Customized Cake (feeds 8-10) $99.95

Pull-a-part Cupcake “Cakes”

18 cupcakes $78.95

24 cupcakes $98.95

4” Single Layer 1st Birthday Smash Cake (feeds 1 baby). $14.95

(addition décor fee applies for additional décor other than writing and simple border) 

Using Format